Sharon Boyd, Editor/Publisher

          DallasArena.com
Your alternative to
The Dallas Managed News  
            
Preservation Nazis are Hypocrites

  Home       Search     

               

BadDealLogo.gif (6018 bytes)


 


                             

11/29/04 What about saving our heritage?

Lots of people have me on their information e-mail list, so I get announcements about doings about town among community activists.  Recently, I got a report on a series of community meetings regarding teardowns.  These are very insider terms used as shorthand for "we know better than you what your property should look like".

Anyway, one of the circulated info-mails named some of the people meeting who want to CONTROL your world.  When I recognized one name as a TENANT who doesn't even own a car, much less real estate or a home, I was outraged.  I know, I know -- Sharon Boyd is prone to outbursts of outrage, but this was definitely a bigger outburst than usual.

I replied to the person who sent me the info-mail with the following:

Until recently, I supported preservation efforts, but I now oppose control freaks who want to tell homeowners what they can and cannot do with their residential property.  I always oppose changing from single-family to multi-family, but as long as someone builds a single-family residence within side, front and back yard setback restrictions, they should be left alone to do
just that. 

If you buy property in a neighborhood with deed restrictions and an existing conservation district, follow the rules you bought under.  I live in a 50+ year old neighborhood.  Many houses have foundation problems and other types of neglect because we had so many aging homeowners who sold to buyers who could not take care of the houses.  To ask future homeowners to live with
houses that don't meet their needs or wants is wrong.

I'm considering building a second floor on my home because I want more space in the house I love and neighborhood I love in an area convenient to me and my work.  If the conservation Nazis have their way, I cannot make my house meet my needs and it will diminish in value for a future sale.

Whether a house is 1-story or 2-story or more should be no one's concern, except the homeowner.  Limiting new construction to existing setbacks is restriction enough.  People don't want to live in shoe boxes anymore, much less neighborhoods where all the houses look the same.

There is some racism among the Conservation Nazis because Dallas, Carrollton, Farmers Branch are increasingly Hispanic.  Many Hispanic families have several children, as well as multi-generations in one household.  Limiting houses in older neighborhoods to one-story and cottage size effectively excludes many Hispanic families.

I no longer trust government or "community leaders" who confuse preservation with control.  A friend of mine says "If you want to save an old house -- buy it."  I think she's right on the money.

I particularly resent tenants who have never owned anything (not even a car), trying to dictate to property owners what their home is supposed to look like.  Squatting in an area does not give you a say in what others can do with their property, when they are not increasing density -- just making their homes more suitable to their needs.

Something to think about.

The lady circulating the info-mail is one of the good guys, but it's bad news for Dallas when a bunch of busybody do-gooders can make decisions that impact your property rights and you aren't even aware of their plans until you read about it in The Dallas Managed News after it's been approved by the city council.

Never assume these do-gooders have all the facts.  They have an agenda and only invite like-minded folks to play with them. 

It may seem to be contradictory for me to support homeowners on Forest Lane who are fighting those mini-lots on the North side.  The developer wants to change the zoning to allow increased density on his property.  I don't support increased density anywhere in our overly-congested city.  We should be reducing density.  The guy bought property in an area where the normal lot size is large.  He knew where he was buying.  If he wanted to develop mini-lot homes, he should have picked another part of town.    
Citizen J:
Great comments this week, Sharon. Couldn't agree with you more.

   Those damn builders/developers don't have to answer to anyone.  Hell, they don't even have to be "licensed" in Texas!
   I have recently become a licensed Realtor and was SHOCKED to learn builders or developers don't even have to be licensed in Texas, let alone regulated.
   They are doing the same thing over here all along Northwest Highway in the Midway area tearing down 1/4 and 1/2 acre lots and throwing up zero lot line townhouses priced between 400 K and 1 Million. 10-14 units where there used to be 2 houses.
   Buy the land cheap, develop it, cram as much *@#* on it as possible, and then "flip it" at a criminal price and move on to do the same HARM elsewhere!!!
 

If the land is already zoned for what he wants and he wants to build purple townhouses as ugly as the toad stool house on Beverly (Park Cities), then let him.  Unfortunately for this particular developer, he does need a zoning change and a bunch of nearby property owners are opposing him big time.  Unfortunately for the opposition, ward politics at City Hall will overcome the 2/3 votes at council needed to override 20% opposition from property owners within 500 feet.  Their council representative is Lois Finkelman who put Bruce Wilkie on the P&Z (Mayor Miller made him chair).  His public comments indicate he will support the zoning change request.  Even though she claims to be an environmentalist, Finkelman will probably follow Wilkie's lead and support this really bad zoning case which will result in huge loss of trees and diminish an "urban forest" that real people actually see every day.  Finkelman claims to be an environmental consultant -- but obviously not for the side of those who want to protect our urban forests.

The Preservation Nazis are not saying a word about this desecration to the status quo of Forest Lane.  Instead, they are trying to tell homeowners in old neighborhoods they cannot replace the house on their own property with something more suitable to their needs and wants.  That means those young, dual income families will spend their money in the suburbs where they can get more city service and build homes that fit their needs.

While the Preservation Nazis are ranting about "teardowns" (replacing old houses with new houses that may not look like the old house), Our Downtown Betters and Our Mayor are still planning to "tear down" the viaducts that span the Trinity Trough.  The Houston Street Viaduct (formerly the Oak Cliff Viaduct) was built in 1912 and was "billed as the longest reinforced concrete structure in the world."  [Big D, Triumphs and Troubles of an American Supercity in the 20th Century by Darwin Payne, p. 34.] 

This an historic structure that should be celebrated today as it was in 1912, but the Preservation Nazis are supporting Our Mayor's plans to see it demolished and replaced with a String Thing Bridge that has nothing to do with Dallas, Texas.

The String Thing Bridges by Calatrava of Cut and Run Spain are not appropriate for the job at hand.  No more appropriate than the entire Trinity Project, whichever version we have seen since Ron Kirk's big lie in 1998.  The current hypothesis (they still don't have a plan) is all a bunch of loosely connected parts that no one knows will work.  If one component fails, the whole thing fails.     James Northrup:
   Last
Wednesday - DMN Metro Section - I 30 Calatrava article says matter of factly that "Woodall Rodgers Bridge is fully funded".
  
Again, by whom? When?
 

Texans have shared in the $14+ billions that have gone into the Boston Big Dig.

Big Dig Leaks Even More Widespread
Wednesday, Nov. 17, 2004
  BOSTON (AP) - Leaks in the Big Dig highway tunnel system are more widespread than state officials have acknowledged, and top construction managers had warned as far back as 1998 about problems that could cause failures in tunnel waterproofing, the Boston Globe reported Wednesday.
   Earlier this month, independent engineers hired by the state to investigate a huge September leak in the Interstate 93 tunnel said the $14.6 billion Big Dig tunnels, which sit almost entirely within the salty water table underlying downtown Boston, were riddled with more than 400 leaks. Project managers and state officials have insisted that the tunnels are safe for motorists.
   Now, documents obtained by The Boston Globe show there are nearly 700 leaks in a single 1,000-foot section of the I-93 tunnels beneath the South Station train terminal.
   And records show that since early 2001 project managers have collectively signed off on at least $10 million in cost overruns to repair leaks and water damage in the costliest highway project in U.S. history.
...In September, an 8-inch leak flooded the northbound I-93 tunnel....

Everyone is pointing fingers at who is to blame, but it was risky business from the get-go, and it looks like our $14+ billions are just the beginning of what it will take to make the tunnel safe for vehicular traffic.  That's being optimistic and assuming it can be fixed.

What Our Mayor and the ODB have planned for the Trinity Trough is just as experimental and iffy and very likely to cause more problems than it fixes.

In Los Angeles, they are having to deal with an environmental problem caused by another Euro Egg Head who doesn't understand Texas or California heat.

   LOS ANGELES - The mirror-like, curving steel walls of the Walt Disney Concert Hall may soon lose some of their luster.
   The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is considering whether to sandblast portions of the walls to reduce glare that has been blamed for blinding drivers and increasing heat in neighboring buildings.
... After receiving complaints from a nearby homeowners group, the county hired consultants to work with architect Frank Gehry before the hall's dedication in October 2003 on reducing the glare from the building.
   A gray mesh fabric was placed over one curved tower across from the condominium unit as an interim solution.
... Gehry could not be reached for comment by the Daily News of Los Angeles. Among his more famous works is the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain. ...

Please the link to see the picture of the ridiculous design of the Hall.  Putting a reflective metal skin on a building in Los Angeles makes as much sense as turning the glass wall of the Meyerson into the Southern sun in Dallas.

We "little people" are not supposed to challenge the great minds of our superiors.  We are not expected to be able to share the great visions of our superiors because we don't share their intellect.  You know -- a lack of breeding or the right schools and all that.

We are just supposed to pay the bills for their screw-ups.

It may seem a stretch from a developer wanting to ruin Forest Lane to the Trinity Project to the Boston Big Dig to Frank Gehry's monstrosity in Los Angeles, but the common denominator is a lack of common sense.

Something happens to some people when they get some authority.  They leave their common sense at home.  They buy into the giant scam that Our Downtown Betters are smarter than us, have more inside information than us and do the vision thing better than us -- because they are richer than us and that makes them smarter than us.  Basically, the vision thing is a product of the gene pool thing -- or so they would have us believe.


Common sense seems to be lost on the Preservation Nazis, too.  They only care about control, not about real needs of real people. 

Don't get me wrong, I love old things.  I love our Trinity Viaducts.  I don't understand the ambivalence of the Preservation Nazis about the pending demolition of these turn of the century structures.

I love my old house (50+ years), even it still needs lots of work.  I bought the property for the house, not for the lot, but I love working in the yard more than doing house work.  Still, it's my house, and I have the right to change it any way I want, provided I don't violate deed restrictions.  Other people should not tell my neighborhood what we are supposed to look like -- certainly no loser who has never owned a piece of property in his life.

As a recovering "community activist" who now only serves on two or three committees, rather than dozens, I know these Preservation Nazis well.  Most originally have good intentions, but they start feeding on each other and morph from community activists to control freaks.

Hypocrisy is second nature to control freaks and Preservation Nazis.  

sb

 

                                        

    





                            

 

  Ward politics is the Devil's key to the soul of the city council.  It is how some council members got themselves in trouble in the past.  It is the bait that will get others in trouble in the future. 4/6/8